Muddy Paws Deaths Remembered

Residents and their dogs filled a room at the Vernon Hills Petco on Feb. 5 to remember the 17 dogs who died of neglect at what was once a Deer Park animal shelter.

“Let’s not forget,” said Sandy Wisniewski, founder of Animal Education and Rescue (AEAR). “If you see something that looks bad, call. Make a call to someone for the animals who can’t speak for themselves.”

Kim Clark, who works for the Lake County State’s Attorney, which is investigating the case, said she has talked to many people who told her they thought there was something strange about the Muddy Paws animal facility, but they did not call.

Wisniewski said she often sees cases of animal abuse and neglect in her work with AEAR, based in Libertyville, but this case was especially disturbing.

“I started to not be able to sleep at night. I knew that the ones who survived would be OK. The ones who didn’t, were just gone. How could we not do something to honor these animals?” Wisnieski asked. “They died horrific deaths.”

Wisniewski said the situation reminded her of stories she had heard when she was a child of the Holocaust, and how she was told that it was important to remember.

The animals were discovered dead of dehydration and starvation in December after authorities were called to the home by Kurt Eldrup, husband of the shelter's operator. Diane Eldrup has been charged with 32 counts of animal cruelty and animal torture. She is free on $25,000 bond.

The service at Petco honored the dogs who died, and also honored the four dogs who survived. Two of the dogs, Lily and Yanna, have already been adopted.

Foster parent Shelly Stefanic said Sasha and Gertie are doing well at her home. “They’re not going anywhere until we find the perfect match,” she said.

Clark said the dogs have gained about 10 to 12 pounds each and have made an amazing recovery.

“It has been very therapeutic to see how great they are doing,” said Clark after the service.

The service included prayers for the dogs. Members of the AEAR Youth Group drew cards with the animal’s names and recited memorials.

Humane volunteer Nancy Genson said the dogs deserved a better life and she hoped that the tragedy will build an awareness of animal cruelty.

“Let’s not forget the survivors. They now have warm beds and the nutritious meals they deserve. I wish love, light and peace for all the animals and all of us here today,” Genson said.

She added that each of the animals that died has a home with the kids in the Youth Group and with the people who attended the memorial.