Carbone Says Challenges are Worth the Gains

District 46 school board member pledges to move forward despite recent controversies.

District 46 board member Michael Carbone has been publicly censured and openly criticized by fellow board members and at least one citizen in the weeks preceding the April 5 elections.

“They have nothing positive to say because their campaigns were exposed and their nepotism and cronyism was exposed,” said Carbone. "This job is not about me. It’s about the parents and taxpayers. I have gone around neighborhoods and talked to hundreds of people. I hope the board takes more responsibility because of me."

Carbone questioned several actions of his fellow District 46 board members. The actions included: hiring former board member Michael Linder and board president Mary Garcia’s husband; incumbent board candidates, Sue Facklam and Mary Garcia, being accused of using the district to distribute campaign flyers; and the Lake County Federation of Teachers (LCFT) being accused of sending a mailing to district staff to support the incumbents.

“In all fairness, we (the board) do get things done,” said Carbone. "It has been a fight, but it’s good to challenge each other. We did save $6 million this past year without cutting jobs or programs."

Carbone also has faced his own detractors. Some of the criticisms against Carbone related to comments he made during an appearance on a Champion Radio talk show January 9 where people said Carbone said he believed that raising class sizes to significantly higher levels was OK.

“I was on the show because it was a hot topic that was relevant,” Carbone said. "Our district had just issued bonuses at a time I thought we could use the money elsewhere. Superintendent (Ellen) Correll made the decision on the distribution, not the board. If you take the time to listen, my comments were taken out of context. I did not say having 40 to 50 kids in a classroom was OK.  The host was referring to when we were young. I agreed that times have changed. That would not happen today if only for school codes."

During the podcast, Carbone did express his concern about annual automatic pay raises for teachers, while others are out of work and have no income. “It’s sort of like putting the cart before the horse,” said Carbone.

At last week’s Special Board meeting, Correll said she will be hiring a mediator at approximately $250 per hour to help sort out issues that had been previously handled by the school district’s attorney.

“While we don’t want to spend the money, this is about the same as what we pay an attorney and will provide the objectivity we need,” said Correll.

Carbone questioned that decision, as well as questioning the reason he was censured in public during a recent school board meeting.

“Where is my due process? The incumbents will have the accusations made against them handled by the district. I’m censured without representation. It should go both ways,” Carbone said.

Carbone was an uncontested write-in candidate in his run for the school board two years ago, so he still has another two years to go on his term. He is not up for re-election and looks forward to continued work with the board.

“I have helped with improving transparency in the district. The financial records are there," Carbone said. "The finance committee was my recommendation and helped us determine how to save the $6 million. I have also supported having students attend the board meetings to talk about classes, sports and their activities. It builds leadership and sets the tone for the district."

The implication has been made that Carbone is supporting one or two of the new candidates in Tuesday’s election. “Hypothetically, if I’m tied to any of the candidates there’s nothing wrong with that. The current board members are supporting the incumbents,” said Carbone.

At least one new board member will take a seat after Tuesday's election. Five candidates, including incumbents Facklam and Garcia, along with Kip Evans, Marchell Norris and Shannon Smigielski, are running for three open positions on the board.

“That will bring a new energy. Each of the candidates running would bring something positive. We are a financially healthy district, but will continue to have challenges ahead of us in the next two to four years, whether it is a good or poor economy,” he said.  

Carbone said that while the other board members are angered by his actions, “I believe I’m just doing my job.”

Lennie Jarratt April 03, 2011 at 09:45 PM
Thank you Michael Carbone for standing up for the taxpayers, parents and students of D46.
Carl April 04, 2011 at 03:12 AM
Lennie likes the last word and front page. He has a lot to say for one who doesn't pay the taxes he protests so strongly.
D46 Parent April 04, 2011 at 01:19 PM
In that now widely circulated radio podcast, Mr. Carbone did not once agree "that times have changed," with regard to class size. In fact, he stated: "Look at it like this; we’re a product of our environment, we’re a species, we adapt. Um, we get into high school with a class of maybe 50, 60, 70 kids,” clearly implying that children can adapt to larger class size. When the host mentioned enormous class sizes of previous years, Mr. Carbone replied, “It’s a great point, because I came from a class out of 35, 40 kids, grade school. My friends who were in parochial school had 50, 60 kids…” Though School Code may limit the far upper end of class size, Mr. Carbone's comments, paired with a statement he made in a December 30, 2011 Trib Local article, wherein his very first suggestion while discussing the merits of flattening the levy was to INCREASE CLASS SIZES, are a red flag for parents in this district. As a district resident, parent, and taxpayer, I am offended by Mr. Carbone's alleged actions, by his participation in this radio talk show, and by the many lies he expressed during that show. He is not a watchdog for me, and I resent his grandstanding and constant use of that phrase to create a heroic image for himself. http://www.championnews.net/talk/mp3s/Champion_News_010911_Full_Show.mp3
Carl April 06, 2011 at 01:24 AM
Lennie... I'm havin' a cup of COFFEE!!! (no tea in d46)
Lennie Jarratt April 06, 2011 at 03:23 AM
Congrats to Shannon, Kip and Sue.
Brad Faxton May 03, 2011 at 07:03 PM
YEA! We need to stick it to those kids! Woo!
Andrea Johnson May 04, 2011 at 03:28 AM
If this link is true some District 46 board members have committed a serious crime. Please look into this Patch! http://illinoisreview.typepad.com/illinoisreview/2011/05/district-46s-board-member-emails-dont-let-them-turn-us-in.html
Tim Froehlig May 04, 2011 at 04:31 AM
Here's the smoking gun! http://lakecountyteaparty.com/2011/05/03/crimes-corruption-and-lies-in-grayslake-d46. Click on the downloadable PDF files, and if you have Adobe reader you can search through the e-mail files. Search the words "cash" and "gift cards." There are also some suspicious e-mails that seem to imply people are trying to skirt election laws as well.
Tim Froehlig May 04, 2011 at 04:46 AM
As a District 46 taxpayer, I am more and more disgusted by the moment at what I am still sitting and reading. Just how deep does this apparent corruption go? I have read through hundreds of pages of e-mails now, and it just gets worse and more suspicious with every page I read on this link above. This is a huge deal, and it needs an immediate investigation. Because now there is a ton of proof in the form of hundreds of pages of incriminating e-mail messages obtained through the FOIA that is there for anyone to view on the link I just posted. As a District 46 taxpayer independent from Patch, I would suggest that any and all members of the District 46 board involved in any of these alleged activities resign immediately. This is my personal opinion and does not necessarily reflect that of patch.com. However, I am EXTREMELY upset and disturbed at what I continue to sit here and read that is CLEARLY corruption at the very least, and it appears that some laws have been seriously violated too.
Sully May 04, 2011 at 04:55 AM
So, regarding Carbone and Lennie, how nice to see the puppet master and puppet schmoozing together outside the middle school after the board meeting tonight. Well done gents! Let's see what else you can come up with to screw the students of District 46! As usual, tea party self-interest rules the day. Now, since Lennie and his wife seem to know so much about education, I'd kind of like to know their educational backgrounds. Usually one likes to hear from experts regarding a chosen issue, so Lennie, I'd love to know your credentials. And I'd love to see the curriculum you present to your children and your methods for instruction.
Tim Froehlig May 04, 2011 at 04:58 AM
Hey Sullivan, I guess you didn't see the link that shows all the corruption going on that I posted about all the people you continue to defend. http://lakecountyteaparty.com/2011/05/03/crimes-corruption-and-lies-in-grayslake-d46. Click on the downloadable PDF files, and if you have Adobe reader you can search through the e-mail files. Search the words "cash" and "gift cards." There are also some suspicious e-mails that seem to imply people are trying to skirt election laws as well.
Sully May 04, 2011 at 05:00 AM
So I've gotten thru Page 9 of the "incriminating" email, request #1 ...I'm still waiting for something. When will it show up?
Tim Froehlig May 04, 2011 at 05:05 AM
Clear as day in this link. http://lakecountyteaparty.com/2011/05/03/crimes-corruption-and-lies-in-grayslake-d46. Click on the downloadable PDF files on the page at the bottom of the link, and if you have Adobe reader you can search through the e-mail files. Search the words "cash" and "gift cards." I'm not going to spell it out any clearer. There are also some e-mails that seem to imply people are trying to skirt election laws as well. Have fun, there's almost 300 pages of e-mails in the first link alone.
Sully May 04, 2011 at 05:08 AM
Page 27 and still waiting... How much money was wasted on this Lennie?
Sully May 04, 2011 at 05:15 AM
Oh for pete's sake- this is ridiculous! maybe the second request will show something.
Tim Froehlig May 04, 2011 at 05:16 AM
Try page 163 and 216, clear as day!
Tim Froehlig May 04, 2011 at 05:25 AM
Page 163, using gift cards as a bribe to get students to register to vote, on school property, through a school board member's kid. Not to mention, the e-mail is sent from a different school district's e-mail address, funded by taxpayers. They even mention to be careful not to be caught because it is likely illegal, and brag about how last time they registered 115 students to vote in one day...and I guess it's okay to "bribe" kids with gift cards so they register to vote, and to ask people to do so on a school district e-mail address? Are you KIDDING ME??????????
Sully May 04, 2011 at 05:32 AM
So you have to go through 163 pages to get to the first real issue, and then to 216 to get to the second? Why all the BS in between? And I will look. I responded first.
Sully May 04, 2011 at 05:46 AM
Okay Tim... score one for you! Most certainly clear wrongdoing on the part of Facklam and Garcia on 163. Was Ellen involved? However, the question remains- do the children of D146 pay the price? Mary is gone, and campaigning tricks used in a school board election, while dirty, unethical, and undesirable, don't quite rate as a huge huge priority for anyone who recognizes the future of the students is in peril. Not spending money for education is in my opinion, much more dangerous. And with that, I sign off for now. It's late.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »